The Pen. chronicle sums up Anian II as the best and stoutest upholder ever seen of the rights of his bishopric — a description fully borne out by the events of his career. At the time of his elevation, the diocese was, as the outcome of the treaty of Montgomery , entirely dominated by Llywelyn ap Gruffydd . Prince and bishop were, at first, on amicable terms. On 1 May 1269 , agreement was reached between them at Mold as to the maintenance of the ancient privileges of the see in the Middle Country . Anian was a party to the settlement between Llywelyn and David arrived at in the same year at Berriw , and also to the compact between Llywelyn and Rhodri executed at Caernarvon on 12 April 1272 . On 30 Oct. 1272 he appears as the prince's envoy to Henry III , then nearing his end, and is praised by the king as having well performed his task. But Llywelyn 's veiled hostility to the new sovereign brought about a change in Anian also. At the end of 1273 he wrote to Gregory X making charges against the prince , which, on 7 March 1274 , were warmly denied in a joint missive of the Welsh Cistercian abbots , assembled at Strata Florida . Later in the year, on 19 Oct. , a full assembly of the clergy of the diocese drew up, at the instance of Anian , a statement of the matters at issue between him and Llywelyn . The quarrel went on during 1275 ; on 25 May of that year the prince wrote at length to archbishop Kilwardby , complaining of the attacks upon him and offering to accept any reasonable solution. As war became imminent, Anian turned to the king ; on 8 Nov. he obtained from him a confirmation of the ancient liberties of the see, repeated on 20 Jan. 1276 . He was present at the council which, at Westminster , on 12 Nov. , declared Llywelyn a rebel , and, on his return to S. Asaph , issued, with his chapter, a detailed catalogue of grievances against him. During the ensuing struggle he was on the king 's side, and he appears in the treaty of Conway ( 9 Nov. 1277 ) as one of the royal councillors who are to escort the prince to Rhuddlan .
That treaty had the effect of removing almost the whole of Anian 's diocese from the control of Llywelyn to that of the Crown . It was with Edward he had now to deal, and for some years their relations were cordial enough. He acted as one of the king's justice s at Oswestry on 27 Nov. 1277 , and about the same time received a grant of arable land in the S. Asaph region of the annual value of £20, to be divided equally between him and the chapter , in compensation, most likely, for losses suffered during the late war. In the summer of 1281 , bishop and king combined in an appeal to the Holy See for leave to remove the seat of the bishopric from the rural isolation of S. Asaph to the new royal stronghold of Rhuddlan — a proposal carried no further. The harmony did not last long. At the outbreak of the war in 1282 , there was fighting between English and Welsh around Rhuddlan , which involved S. Asaph and the burning of the cathedral. Anian was beyond measure angry; he quitted the diocese and gave no further aid to the campaign, being the only bishop of the province of Canterbury who did not join in the excommunication of the Welsh rebels . Edward was not slow to retaliate; he ordered the confiscation of Anian 's goods and, even after the fall of Llywelyn , would not suffer him to return to his see.
The rupture lasted for more than two years; at last, the efforts of archbishop Peckham to restore peace were successful. In the summer of 1284 Anian consented to pay 500 marks as the price of the king 's good will and further mollified him by withdrawing his opposition to the transfer of the abbey of Conway to the proposed new site at Maenan . Edward , in return, gave him the advowson of Rhuddlan .
Meanwhile he had waged many conflicts with less exalted opponents. From 1269 to 1272 he supported John Fitz Alan in his suit against Shrewsbury abbey for the patronage of Oswestry . In 1279 he was at odds with the prior of Chirbury , and in 1274 with the abbey of Valle Crucis , as to vicarages in the churches which it held in the district. A major conflict was that which Anian waged with the see of Hereford for episcopal authority in the region of Gorddwr , which lay along the right bank of the Severn from Montgomery to Alberbury . He was emboldened to put forward this claim by the success of Gruffydd ap Gwenwynwyn in 1263 in annexing this territory to southern Powys . Its recovery by Peter Corbet in 1276 did not daunt Anian ; he carried on the strife for years, until at last bishop Swinfield won a final victory in 1288 .
He d. on 5 Feb. 1293 . His will, made at Chartham , near Canterbury , in 1288 , shows him as the owner of considerable personal property. His very numerous bequests were, for the most part, devoted to religious and charitable purposes in his own diocese.
Sir John Edward Lloyd, D.Litt., F.B.A., F.S.A. (1861-1947), Bangor
Published date: 1959