Ab Ithel had but little scholarship; moreover, such critical faculties as he had were wrecked when he became involved in the romantic inventions of Iolo Morganwg and his school — more particularly Myfyr Morganwg ( Evan Davies , 1801 - 1888 ) . Unfortunately, he was by this time generally regarded, except by a few people of more balanced judgement, as the principal Welsh scholar of his day , and his name was considered in all seriousness for the proposed chair of Celtic in the University of Oxford . He started the Cambrian Institute and its periodical, the Cambrian Journal , which he edited from 1854 until his death. He became the leading light in the Welsh Manuscripts Society , and edited four of its publications; worse still, on the death of Aneurin Owen he was appointed by the government ( 1858 ) to complete the plan of publishing the old Welsh chronicles — Annales Cambriae and Brut y Tywysogion appeared in 1860 . His editorial work was shot to pieces by later critics — not only because he was quite incapable of editing old manuscripts diplomatically but because he plagiarised the ideas of men like Aneurin Owen and Thomas Rowland without acknowledgement. But the high-water mark of his folly was the ‘ Great Llangollen Eisteddfod ’ ( 1858 ), organised by himself and his friends such as Môr Meirion ( R. W. Morgan ) and Carn Ingli ( Joseph Hughes ) , which aroused derision and shame among his fellow-countrymen — his own family ‘won’ several of the prizes, and Thomas Stephens was the subject of an iniquitous decision because he had the audacity to suggest that the story of Madoc was not true. For all that, the 1858 eisteddfod was an important milestone in the history of the national eisteddfod — no thanks to the promoters.
On the other hand, we cannot for one moment deny Ab Ithel 's industry, both within the Church and outside it, nor his wholehearted patriotism. He was an exceedingly devoted parish priest , and in addition supervised ‘Madam Bevan's’ schools in North Wales , as well as the church schools in the diocese of S. Asaph . He was the first priest to serve the new parish of Rhosygwaliau . He was a High-churchman (but not a ritualist), and in 1850 he did his best to organize a protest against the decision of the Privy Council in the notorious Gorham case. He worked so hard that he had two nervous break-downs — in 1849 , when he was temporarily transferred to the lighter parish of Llangorwen, Cards. ; and in 1855 when he was forced to take sick leave for nearly two years. In March 1862 , he was transferred from Llan-ym-Mawddwy (where his successor was Daniel Silvan Evans ) to Llanenddwyn and Llanddwywe in Ardudwy . But, by this time, his health had broken down completely, and he d. 27 Aug. 1862 ; he was buried in Llanddwywe churchyard. His widow, Elizabeth , received a civil pension, 18 June 1873 .
Emeritus Professor Robert Thomas Jenkins, C.B.E., D.Litt., Ll.D., F.S.A., (1881-1969), Bangor
Published date: 1959